Throughout world war ii and the holocaust, pope pius xii saw his role as a neutral diplomat, and so he spoke of the jews’ persecution only in the formal papal language of generalities and tried to bring peace without condemning any nation. Pope pius xii's (1876-1958) actions during the holocaust remain controversial for much of the war, he maintained a public front of indifference and remained silent while german atrocities were committed. It's hard for me to see how an encyclical by his predecessor (admittedly, very likely with his input) written several years before the holocaust started, that made no mention of jews or judaism can be relevant to pius xii and the holocaust. Pius xii's famous christmas broadcast on the vatican radio delivered december 24, 1942—which at 26 pages and over 5000 words took more than 45 minutes to deliver—remains a lightning rod in debates about pope pius xii during the war, particularly the holocaust. The vatican will open secret archives on saturday in an effort to allay accusations that pope pius xii, whom the vatican wants to make a saint, did not do enough to save jews from the holocaust.
About pope pius xii and the holocaust collaborative effort by a number of the world's leading experts on the holocaust lively, but not sensationalistic, this book is balanced but on the cutting edge of one of the most important debates in this field: how should vatican policies during world war ii be understood. Pope pius xii has received particular attention, scrutiny, even condemnation in this regard his alleged “silence” in the face of hitler’s extermination of europe’s jews has been the focus of numerous books, many of them far more polemical than scholarly. The ongoing debate about pope pius xii (eugenio pacelli) and his actions (or lack of actions) in response to the holocaust has gained intensity over the past few years books defending the pontiff by ronald j rychlak, pierre blet, margherita marchione, and ralph mcinerny have been matched by others .
Pope pius xii did what he could to calmly deal with the situation of the holocaust and he did attempt to resist it, but an active role in resistance was impossible for him and the vatican in general. For nearly 20 years after world war ii, pope pius xii (1939-1958) was honored by the world for his actions in saving countless jewish lives in the face of the nazi holocaust his death on october 9, 1958 brought a moment of silence from leonard bernstein while he conducted at new york’s carnegie . Pius xii and the holocaust: understanding the controversy [jose m sanchez] on amazoncom free shipping on qualifying offers pope pius xii's alleged silence in the face of the destruction of the european jews during world war ii has been the subject of a fierce controversy that has continued unabated ever since rolf hochhuth's the deputy made the charge so spectacularly in 1963. Pope pius xii was a diplomat and not a radical preacher he knew that he first needed to preserve vatican neutrality so that vatican city could be a refuge for war victims the international red .
About pope pius xii and the holocaust this collaborative effort by a number of the world's leading experts on the holocaust examines the question: how should vatican policies during world war ii be understood. Catholic church and the holocaust any analysis of the role of the church and the pope in the holocaust will be controversial, emotionally laden and political it is a complex and complicated story, that cannot be easily summarized in broad strokes. The current desire of the roman catholic church to canonize as saint pope pius xii has produced in its wake a flurry of publications, both pro and con, revisiting his performance during the horrendous period of the second world war, and, in particular, his attitude and behavior regarding the fate of the jews in the holocaust of shoah.
The start of the pontificate of pius xii occurred at the time of the second world war and the nazi holocaust, which saw the industrialized mass murder of millions of jews and others by adolf hitler's germany. A pope is the leader of a religious institution and as such he is charged with the responsibility for the spiritual welfare of the faithful of that institution, a fact often forgotten in the historiographical controversy surrounding pius he was an intensely spiritual person he wrote a number of . In recent years, eugenio pacelli, who became pope pius xii in 1939, has been the subject of considerable public criticism, and even vilification, for his alleged failure to speak out against hitler during the holocaust.
Church of spies: the pope’s secret war against hitler by mark riebling basic books, new york, 2015 375 pages, $2999 ronald j rychlak pope pius xii and the nazis: far too many writers have wandered into this fascinating subject without bringing anything new to the table. Pius xii: pope pius xii, head of the and soviet regimes, the horror of the holocaust, pius—the first pope to use radio extensively—made a series of . The public statements of pope pius xii on the holocaust, or lack thereof, are one of the most controversial elements of the historical debate about pope pius xii and the holocaust.